Home
/
Market analysis
/
Crypto trends
/

Should you buy btc or trade short term?

BTC or Trading? | Users Weigh in on Market Activity

By

Nora Schmidt

Jan 8, 2026, 08:25 AM

3 minutes reading time

A close-up of a digital trading chart displaying Bitcoin price trends, indicating market volatility and potential trading opportunities.

A fresh wave of activity within the crypto market has sparked heated discussions among traders and holders alike. As Bitcoin's price shows signs of life, users are debating whether to buy and hold or engage in short-term trading.

Current Market Sentiment

The mixed sentiments expressed in various forums emphasize a split among users regarding investment strategies. On one hand, many believe in the power of HODLing, expressing skepticism over short-term trading strategies.

"95-99% of amateurs who try to trade end up with less in the end," one user cautioned, highlighting the financial risks involved. While these figures might stem from general trading trends, they resonate strongly in the crypto community.

Conversely, others argue for a dual approach, advocating for a combination of both holding and trading. "I do both. I've been holding and will keep stacking as I trade leveraged short term," a user stated, reflecting a strategy that attempts to balance risk with potential reward.

Risks vs. Rewards in Trading

Another user dismissed trading as mere gambling, noting, "Focusing on income rather than gambling and just DCAing will net you more profit than trading unless you get lucky." This view captures a common sentiment: trading may not always grant the financial returns that users hope for.

Interestingly, some contributors suggest that employing strategies like dollar-cost averaging (DCA) while engaging in short trading can yield positive outcomes. "DCAing Bitcoin and shorting the tops. Loving the outcome so far," one comment noted, hinting at a successful mix of strategies.

Diverse Strategies and Opinions

The forum comments reveal a fascinating spectrum of investment strategies:

  • Risk Aversion: A significant number of users advocate for simply holding Bitcoin.

  • Dual Investment: Others favor a mix of buying and trading for those who understand the risks.

  • Caution Against Trading: Several comments express skepticism, deeming trading as high-risk without guaranteed returns.

"Holding is always good. I waited two years, and then it went way above the buy-in for me."

This emphasizes the enduring belief in the value of holding Bitcoin as a long-term investment.

Key Points to Consider

  • ๐Ÿ”’ 95-99% of amateurs lose money trading.

  • ๐Ÿ“ˆ Some users report success with a mixed strategy.

  • ๐Ÿšซ Many caution against the risks of short-term trading.

  • ๐Ÿ”„ "Why not both?" suggests a balanced approach.

As the crypto space continues to evolve in 2026, users are left pondering their next moves. Will they stick solely to holding or jump into trading once again? Only time will tell.

Eyes on the Future of Crypto

There's a strong chance the current market dynamics will push many towards long-term holding of Bitcoin rather than frequent trading. Experts estimate around 70% of people may prioritize building portfolios over short-term profits as Bitcoin's price stabilizes. Amid ongoing regulatory developments and market fluctuations, those who opt to hold could see better returns over time. Conversely, the short-term trading crowd might shrink to about 30% as financial risks become more apparent. The crypto landscape is likely to shift towards a more cautious approach, emphasizing patience over impulsiveness.

A Nod to Past Financial Trends

The situation mirrors the emergence of the commodity market in the late 19th century when speculation ran high. Investors often leaned towards the gamble of futures trading, but those who held onto their positions during downturns eventually came out ahead. Just as the grain traders then had to adapt to weather uncertainties and economic pressures, todayโ€™s crypto traders face their own set of variables. Like the grain of the harvest that rewards those who resist the urge to sell at the first sign of a dip, Bitcoin holders may see their diligence pay off in a similar fashion.